YAMM (Yet Another Mail Merge) alternative: Replyable compared

Updated

Replyable is a good YAMM alternative if you would rather work from a Gmail side panel than a Google Sheet, schedule up to three follow-ups that send themselves and stop on reply, and grant Google send-only permission. YAMM, with over 16 million installs, is the better choice for spreadsheet-based merges, personalised attachments, tracking on its free plan and lower annual prices.

YAMM (Yet Another Mail Merge) and Replyable both send a personalised copy of one email to each person on a list, from your own Gmail address. They start from different places. YAMM is a Google Sheets add-on: you write a Gmail draft, list recipients in a sheet and launch the merge from the spreadsheet. Replyable is a Chrome extension that opens a side panel in Gmail, where you add contacts, write, review and schedule follow-ups.

This comparison uses YAMM’s pricing page, help documentation and Google Workspace Marketplace listing.

Who each tool suits

YAMM suits people whose contact lists already live in Google Sheets and who like seeing results there. Its listing describes opens, clicks, replies, bounces and unsubscribes written back into the sheet in real time, with tracking on every plan, including Free. It handles personalised attachments, Gmail layouts and custom HTML templates, and a Google Workspace super admin can install it for a whole domain.

Replyable suits founders, freelancers, agencies and small sales teams on Gmail or Google Workspace sending outreach to lists of roughly 50 to 2,000 contacts. You do not need a spreadsheet: upload a CSV or paste rows, review every email, and let up to three follow-ups go out in the same thread until each person replies.

YAMM and Replyable at a glance

Replyable YAMM
Price Free £0; Starter £15/month; Pro £35/month (GBP, billed monthly) Free. For UK billing: Pro gmail.com 6 USD/month, billed annually at 72 USD; Pro Google Workspace or Team 12 USD/month per user, billed annually at 144 USD. Excludes taxes; prices vary by billing country
Daily sending limit Free 50; Starter 400; Pro 1,500. Never above 450 on @gmail.com or 1,800 on Google Workspace Free 20 recipients; Pro gmail.com 400; Pro Google Workspace and Team 1,500 per user (400 for new Workspace accounts for a while)
Follow-ups Up to 3 per campaign (Free: 1), scheduled when you set up the campaign; sent in the same thread after a set number of days; stop on reply, bounce or unsubscribe On every plan. You run a follow-up from the tracking report and choose who gets it: people who opened, did not open, did not reply, or everyone; in the same thread or a new one. Bounced and unsubscribed recipients are excluded
AI writing Claude drafts the email from a short brief, in your voice if you add sample emails; writes a one-line personal opening per contact from that contact’s row; can write follow-ups. 50, 1,000 or 5,000 AI credits a month Not stated for the add-on. YAMM offers free AI tools on its website (email writer, subject line generator, grammar fixer, tone rewriter)
Google permissions Send email on your behalf, plus basic profile and email address. No read, modify or delete access Full access to Google Sheets; contacts; read, compose and send Gmail (for drafts and labels); view messages while the add-on runs; send email as you; run when you are not present. Drive access only for personalised attachments
Where you work Side panel in Gmail, opened from under Compose Google Sheets add-on (Extensions menu) with Gmail drafts as templates; companion Gmail add-on and a web dashboard for past campaigns

Prices and limits checked on 18 November 2026.

YAMM’s prices are in US dollars for UK billing and are charged once a year; we have not converted them.

Where YAMM is the better choice

YAMM has been on the Google Workspace Marketplace since the store opened in March 2014. Its listing reports more than 16 million installs and a 4.7 rating from over 18,000 users. Choose YAMM if any of these matter to you:

  • Your list lives in Google Sheets. YAMM works inside the spreadsheet, can skip hidden or filtered rows, and writes each person’s status back next to their row. Replyable takes a copy of your rows as a CSV or paste, and shows results in its own panel.
  • Personalised attachments. YAMM can attach a different file for each recipient from Google Drive. Replyable does not support attachments yet.
  • Tracking on a free plan. YAMM includes open, click and response tracking on Free. Replyable’s optional open tracking is on paid plans only.
  • Lower annual cost. For UK billing, YAMM Pro is 72 USD a year with @gmail.com or 144 USD with Google Workspace. Replyable’s Starter plan is £15 a month, or £180 over a year.
  • Long lists over several days. If a list is longer than your daily limit, YAMM spreads the sending across several days automatically. Replyable caps a campaign at 2,000 contacts.
  • Domain-wide installation. A Workspace super admin can install YAMM for everyone in an organisation.

Where Replyable is a better fit

You would rather not work from a spreadsheet

Replyable keeps the whole campaign in one panel in Gmail: contacts, merge tags with fallbacks such as {{first_name|there}}, AI, review and scheduling. You can step through every contact and see the exact subject and body they will receive, edit any personal line and send yourself a test. For the basics, see how to mail merge in Gmail.

You want follow-ups set up in advance

In YAMM’s documented process, you open the tracking report and run each follow-up when you are ready. In Replyable, you write up to three follow-ups when you create the campaign and choose how many days apart they go. They send automatically in the same thread with a “Re:” subject and stop for anyone who replies, bounces or unsubscribes. Replyable does not count out-of-office auto-replies as replies; YAMM’s blog notes that YAMM counts them as replies, so someone on holiday is left out of a “did not reply” follow-up.

You want a narrower Google permission

YAMM’s permissions guide lists the access it needs to work across Sheets, Gmail, Contacts and Drive, including full access to your spreadsheets and the ability to read, compose and send Gmail. Replyable requests only Google’s “Send email on your behalf” permission plus your basic profile, so its servers never read your inbox. Reply and bounce detection runs in your own browser, and only “this contact replied” or “this contact bounced” reaches Replyable’s server. The trade-off is that follow-ups wait until the extension has checked for replies in the last 24 hours, so you need Gmail open in Chrome once a day.

You want AI lines based on facts you supplied

Replyable’s AI writes a one-sentence opening for each contact using only what is in that contact’s row, such as company, role or notes. If a row has nothing specific, it leaves the line empty rather than inventing something. It can also draft the main email and follow-ups from a short brief, in your own voice if you paste two or three sample emails into Settings.

You want monthly billing in pounds

Replyable is built in the UK and billed monthly in GBP, with a Free plan of 50 emails a day. That suits teams who want to pay as they go rather than commit to a year.

You want compliance checks built in

Before sending, Replyable removes invalid addresses, duplicates, role addresses such as noreply@, domains with no mail server, and anyone who previously unsubscribed or bounced. Every email carries a one-click unsubscribe header and a footer with your name and postal address. Campaigns pause automatically if, after 20 sends, bounces pass 3%, unsubscribes pass 5% or Gmail rejects more than 5%.

Making the choice

If your work centres on Google Sheets, you need personalised attachments, or you want the lowest annual price, YAMM is a well-established choice. If you want to run outreach from Gmail itself, with follow-ups that send and stop on their own and send-only access to your account, Replyable is the closer fit. The Free plan lets you try a real campaign before paying: install Replyable from the Chrome Web Store.

Questions people ask

How many emails a day can I send with YAMM?

YAMM's free plan allows up to 20 recipients a day. Paid plans allow up to 400 a day from an @gmail.com account and up to 1,500 a day per user from a Google Workspace account, with new Workspace accounts limited to 400 for a while. Replyable allows 50, 400 or 1,500 a day depending on plan.

How much does YAMM cost in the UK?

For UK billing, YAMM Pro costs 6 USD a month billed annually at 72 USD with an @gmail.com account, and 12 USD a month billed annually at 144 USD with Google Workspace or per Team user, excluding taxes. Replyable is billed monthly in pounds: £0, £15 or £35.

Do I need a Google Sheet to use Replyable?

No. You can upload a CSV or paste rows copied from Google Sheets or Excel, including the header row, into the Replyable panel in Gmail. The email column is detected automatically.

Does Replyable need permission to read my Gmail?

No. Replyable asks Google only for permission to send email on your behalf, plus your basic profile. Reply and bounce checks run in your browser, and only the fact that a contact replied or bounced is sent to Replyable's server.

Sources