Mailmeteor alternative for Gmail outreach: Replyable compared
Updated
Replyable is a good Mailmeteor alternative if you want outreach run from one Gmail side panel, with send-only Google permission, AI opening lines written from your own contact data, and up to three follow-ups on every paid plan, priced in pounds. Mailmeteor is the better choice if you need Outlook or Excel, attachments, higher daily limits or lower entry prices.
Mailmeteor and Replyable both send personalised emails from your own Gmail account, track who replied, and send follow-ups to people who have not. Mailmeteor is a mature product that works across Gmail, Google Sheets, Excel, Outlook and its own web dashboard. Replyable is a newer Chrome extension focused on one job: personalised outreach and follow-ups from a side panel in Gmail, with the narrowest Google permission that can do it.
This comparison uses Mailmeteor’s own pricing page, help documentation and Chrome Web Store listing.
Who each tool suits
Mailmeteor suits individuals and teams who want one mail merge service across several places they already work. It has a Gmail extension, a Google Sheets add-on, an Excel add-in and a web dashboard, and it connects to Outlook as well as Gmail. Its higher plans add an AI email assistant for your inbox, email warm-up, inbox rotation, CRM integration and Pipelines for tracking conversations. Students and staff with an .edu address can apply for free licences through its education programme.
Replyable suits founders, freelancers, agencies and small sales teams on Gmail or Google Workspace sending to lists of roughly 50 to 2,000 contacts. You add contacts from a CSV or rows pasted from a spreadsheet, review each email before it goes, and let up to three follow-ups go out in the same thread until someone replies.
Mailmeteor and Replyable at a glance
| Replyable | Mailmeteor | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Free £0; Starter £15/month; Pro £35/month (GBP, billed monthly) | Hobby free; Starter $5.99; Premium $17.99; Professional $35.99 per user per month, billed monthly. Yearly: $53.99, $161.99 and $323.99 per user. Also priced in EUR and INR |
| Daily sending limit | Free 50; Starter 400; Pro 1,500. Never above 450 on @gmail.com or 1,800 on Google Workspace | Hobby 50 (500 a month); Starter 250 (5,000 a month); Premium 1,000 (30,000 a month); Professional 2,000 (60,000 a month) |
| Follow-ups | Up to 3 per campaign (Free: 1), in the same thread, after a set number of days; stop on reply, bounce or unsubscribe | Premium and Professional. Conditional follow-ups (no reply, no open, no click, open, click, or always) after minutes, hours or days; the sequence stops when the recipient answers |
| AI writing | Claude drafts the email from a short brief, in your voice if you add sample emails; writes a one-line personal opening per contact from that contact’s row; can write follow-ups. 50, 1,000 or 5,000 AI credits a month | Email writer on every plan. Premium adds the AI Email Assistant: auto labels, drafts in your voice and a full email assistant |
| Google permissions | Send email on your behalf, plus basic profile and email address. No read, modify or delete access | Sheets add-on: Google Sheets access, send email on your behalf, connect to an external service, sidebars. Reply detection, automatic follow-ups and the AI Email Assistant request additional mailbox read and write permissions |
| Where you work | Side panel in Gmail, opened from under Compose | Campaigns tab in Gmail (Chrome extension), Google Sheets add-on, Excel add-in, web dashboard |
Prices and limits checked on 18 November 2026.
Mailmeteor’s prices are in US dollars, per user and exclusive of any taxes; we have not converted them.
Where Mailmeteor is the better choice
Mailmeteor has a much larger user base. Its Gmail extension lists around 70,000 users on the Chrome Web Store with a 4.9 rating, and Mailmeteor states it has 7 million users across its products. It also offers more than Replyable does today:
- Lower entry price. Starter costs $5.99 per user per month, and the free Hobby plan includes scheduling and attachments.
- Higher daily limits. Premium allows 1,000 emails a day and Professional 2,000. Replyable’s highest plan allows 1,500, and less on a free @gmail.com account.
- More places to send from. Mailmeteor works with Outlook, Excel and its dashboard as well as Gmail and Google Sheets. Replyable is Gmail and Google Workspace only.
- Features Replyable does not have. Attachments, email warm-up, inbox rotation, multiple senders, Zapier and CRM integration, and an AI assistant that labels your inbox and prepares replies.
- More follow-up conditions. Mailmeteor can trigger follow-ups on opens and clicks, and send them minutes or hours later. Replyable sends follow-ups after a number of days to anyone who has not replied, bounced or unsubscribed.
Where Replyable is a better fit
You want everything in one Gmail panel
Replyable opens as a side panel from under Compose. Contacts, writing, AI, review, follow-ups and scheduling all happen there, with no dashboard or spreadsheet add-on to switch to. Before sending you can step through every contact, see the exact subject and body they will get, edit any personal line and send yourself a test.
You want follow-ups without granting inbox access
Mailmeteor’s documentation explains that its basic Sheets mail merge does not need inbox read access, but reply detection, automatic follow-ups and the AI Email Assistant do. Replyable runs follow-ups with only Google’s “Send email on your behalf” permission plus your basic profile, so its servers never read your inbox. Reply and bounce detection happens in your own browser, and only “this contact replied” or “this contact bounced” reaches Replyable’s server.
The trade-off is that Replyable’s follow-ups wait until the extension has checked for replies in the last 24 hours, so you need Gmail open in Chrome once a day. You can also mark a contact as replied yourself.
You want follow-ups below the top plans
Replyable includes up to three follow-ups per campaign on Starter at £15 a month, and one on the Free plan. Follow-ups go out in the same Gmail thread with a “Re:” subject and stop automatically for anyone who replies, bounces or unsubscribes. Out-of-office auto-replies do not count as replies. Our guide to automatic follow-up emails in Gmail covers timing and wording.
You want AI lines based on facts you supplied
Replyable’s AI writes a one-sentence opening for each contact using only what is in that contact’s row, such as company, role or notes. If a row has nothing specific, it leaves the line empty rather than inventing something. It can also draft the main email and the follow-ups from a short brief, in your own voice if you paste two or three sample emails into Settings. One AI credit covers one draft or one personal line.
You want UK pricing
Replyable is built in the UK and billed monthly in pounds, so the price you see is the price you pay each month without currency conversion.
You want compliance checks built in
Before sending, Replyable removes invalid addresses, duplicates, role addresses such as noreply@, domains with no mail server, and anyone who previously unsubscribed or bounced. An unknown merge tag without a fallback blocks sending. Every email carries a one-click unsubscribe header and a footer with your name and postal address, and campaigns pause automatically if, after 20 sends, bounces pass 3%, unsubscribes pass 5% or Gmail rejects more than 5%. New to sending from Gmail? Start with how to mail merge in Gmail.
Making the choice
If you need Outlook or Excel, attachments, warm-up, inbox rotation or a CRM link, Mailmeteor offers more and costs less to start. If you work in Gmail, send a few hundred personalised emails a day, and want automatic follow-ups without granting read access to your inbox, Replyable is the closer fit. The Free plan lets you send a real campaign with one follow-up before paying: install Replyable from the Chrome Web Store.
Questions people ask
Is Mailmeteor free?
Yes. Mailmeteor's free Hobby plan allows 500 emails a month with a daily limit of 50, and includes templates, tracking, scheduling and attachments. Replyable's Free plan allows 50 emails a day, 50 AI credits a month and one follow-up per campaign.
Which Mailmeteor plan includes follow-ups?
Mailmeteor's pricing page lists follow-ups on the Premium plan ($17.99 per user per month) and the Professional plan. Replyable includes one follow-up per campaign on Free and up to three on Starter (£15 a month) and Pro (£35 a month).
Does Replyable need permission to read my Gmail?
No. Replyable asks Google only for permission to send email on your behalf, plus your basic profile. Reply and bounce checks run in your browser, and only the fact that a contact replied or bounced is sent to Replyable's server.
Can I send from Outlook with Replyable?
No. Replyable works with Gmail and Google Workspace only. Mailmeteor supports Outlook as well as Gmail.